UK spies violated human rights with bulk intercepts, European rights court rules

The building of the European Court of Human Rights

Britain's GCHQ eavesdropping agency breached fundamental human rights by intercepting and harvesting vast amounts of communications, the European Court of Human Rights ruled on Tuesday, Reuters reports.

The Strasbourg-based court ruled in a case known as "Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom" that the United Kingdom had breached the right to respect for private and family life communications, and the right to freedom of expression with its bulk intercept regime.

Revelations by former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden showed that British and US spy agencies, GCHQ and the NSA, were sucking up vast amounts of communications from across the world.

Civil liberties campaigners brought the case as they contended that so-called bulk interception was neither necessary nor proportionate, and that the system lacked clear definition and lacked judicial oversight.

The British government argued that bulk interception was critical for national security and had enabled it to uncover threats. Essentially, London argued that it had to harvest vast amounts of data to find threats.

The regime for obtaining communications data from service providers also violated human rights, the court said, though it said bulk interception in itself was not illegal.

"The court considered that, owing to the multitude of threats states face in modern society, operating a bulk interception regime did not in and of itself violate the Convention," the court said. "However, such a regime had to be subject to 'end-to-end safeguards'," it said.

The court ruled that there had been no violation of rights by requests for intercepted material from foreign intelligence agencies.

Britain's Home Office (interior ministry) had no immediate comment on the court's decision.

Similar articles

  • UK economic recovery gains speed

    UK economic recovery gains speed

    UK’s economic recovery from the Covid-19 downturn gained speed in April as lockdown measures were eased and industrial activity returned to pre-pandemic levels, Reuters reported. Figures released from the Office for National Statistics confirmed that output edged up 27.6% from a year earlier when the country was practically halted by restrictions.

    36
  • Johnson and Biden to sign new Atlantic charter

    Johnson and Biden to sign new Atlantic charter

    UK PM Boris Johnson and US President Joe Biden will sign a new Atlantic charter in an attempt to show that both countries leaderships plan to frame a post-Covid order in a way the original 1941 charter prefigured a new world order after the Second world war, British media reported.

    37
  • The Vatican makes progress in combating money laundering: report

    The Vatican makes progress in combating money laundering: report

    The Vatican is making progress in the fight against money laundering, according to financial transparency experts from the Council of Europe, dpa reported. "Since the last evaluation, the Holy See/Vatican City State has taken steps to improve its anti-money laundering and combating financing of terrorism framework," a report published by the Council of Europe"s expert committee Moneyval against money laundering and terrorism finance on Wednesday, said.

    31