Auditors: Risk of overestimating EU climate action remains
The methodology used to track the money should be robust and applied consistently across policy areas, the ECA saysEuropost , Brussels
The Commission made a commitment for the 2014-2020 period, to spend at least 20 % of the EU budget on climate action and it has now raised this target to 25 % for the 2021-2027 period. According to a new review by the European Court of Auditors (ECA), setting such targets can be an effective step towards achieving the EU’s climate objectives, as long as the methodology used to track the money is robust and applied consistently across policy areas.
Tackling climate change is a high priority for the EU. Rather than creating a dedicated funding instrument to address climate change, the Commission opted to set a target for the percentage of the EU budget to be spent on climate action. In this context, tracking climate-related spending means measuring the financial contribution made to climate objectives by different EU funding sources, and assessing whether these spending targets have been met.
We all want a genuinely greener EU budget, said Joëlle Elvinger, the member of the European Court of Auditors responsible for the review. She underscored that progress has been made, but the risk of overestimating EU climate action remains. Looking ahead to the post-2020 period, to the Commission’s Green Deal and the more ambitious target of 25 %, we need reliable reporting on climate-related spending, Joëlle Elvinger asserted.
The auditors focused on the tracking of climate action in the policy areas of agriculture, cohesion and research, which together account for the majority of climate-related expenditure. They had previously (special report 31/2016) warned of the risk of falling short of the current 20 % target for EU spending on climate action.
The new review reaffirms their concerns about the Commission’s methodology for tracking climate-related spending. The negative impact of expenditure leading to an increase in emissions was not accounted for. Moreover, it overestimated the extent to which EU spending, and particularly certain common agricultural policy schemes, could contribute to tackling climate change.
In its first proposal for the EU’s long-term budget for 2021-2027, tabled in May 2018, the Commission increased its target for EU spending on climate change from 20 % to 25 %. Its proposal for a European Green Deal in December 2019 confirmed this increase.
The Covid-19 crisis may alter political priorities, shifting the focus towards addressing public health threats, boosting the economy or creating jobs. In May this year, the Commission – at the request of the European Council and the European Parliament – presented a revised proposal for the 2021-2027 MFF period, including a debt-financed recovery plan to address the effects of the pandemic. This proposal is currently under discussion.
The EU’s overall climate-related spending will depend on the outcome of these negotiations and the type of investments on which the additional EU funds will actually be spent. In any case, climate change will remain a global challenge and a central concern for citizens, policymakers and stakeholders.