Apple, Broadcom to pay $1.1bn for patent infringement

This is thought to be one of the largest patent verdicts ever

A Los Angeles jury on Wednesday ordered Apple and Broadcom to pay a total of $1.1bn  to a California university for infringing wifi technology patents in what is thought to be one of the largest patent verdicts ever. In particularly, Apple was ordered to pay $837m and Broadcom must pay $270m  to the California Institute of Technology.

Caltech had sued both tech giants in 2016, alleging that Apple products including iPhones, iPads and Apple Watches used Broadcom components that infringed on its patents related to wireless data transmissions. While Broadcom made the chips at issue in the trial, jurors may have hit Apple with a bigger tab by because it makes billions of dollars selling iPhones and other devices that incorporate the technology.

"Think of the patented technology as a piece of property that was stolen and sold to someone else," said analyst Rob Enderle of Enderle Group.

"It doesn't matter if they had a go-between steal it for them, they were not allowed to benefit from a theft even if they were downstream," he added.

Both Apple and Broadcom planned to appeal the verdict.

"While we thank the members of the jury for their service, we disagree with the factual and legal bases for the verdict and intend to appeal," Broadcom said in response to an AFP inquiry.

In court documents, Apple and Broadcom had said Caltech's claims "are based solely on the incorporation of allegedly infringing Broadcom chips in Apple's iPhone, Mac, and other devices."

"Broadcom manufactures the accused chips, while Apple is merely an indirect downstream party whose products incorporate the accused chips," court filings argued.

Broadcom was the main target of the lawsuit but Apple was also named as it is one of Broadcom's biggest customers.

Caltech welcomed the ruling.

"As a nonprofit institution of higher education, Caltech is committed to protecting its intellectual property in furtherance of its mission to expand human knowledge and benefit society through research integrated with education," the institute said.

Analyst Enderle expected repercussions from the ruling to go beyond Apple to other Broadcom customers who used the chips at issue.

"Caltech will go down the list of Broadcom customers and look for out-of-court settlements with anyone who used the compromised technology," Enderle said.

The analyst wondered whether the jury award signaled a new onslaught of patent battles in the tech industry.

"Typically, we go through waves of patent wars," Enderle said.

"I think it's a case where, after a period of time, people age out or forget that there are significant penalties for this stuff."

Similar articles

  • Covid-19 vaccine makers slump on expected patent waiver

    Covid-19 vaccine makers slump on expected patent waiver

    The stocks of all companies involved in production of Covid-19 vaccines fell, as US and EU backed the call from the World Health Organisation to waive patent rights claims over the jabs production, Reuters reported. The share slumps came even as some analysts raised doubts about any near-term pressure on Covid-19 vaccine sales from discussions of waiving intellectual property rights, given the manufacturing complexity and scarcity of raw materials. Combined, Pfizer and Moderna have forecast a total of over $45 billion in sales this year for their Covid-19 vaccines.

    43
  • Tesla misses key technology target

    Tesla misses key technology target

    The producer of electric cars Tesla admitted it would miss a target set by its majority owner Elon Musk - to develop full self-driving vehicles by the end of 2021, Reuters reported. The announcement seriously undermines Tesla ambitions to influence the global EV market. Documents released in media earlier this week showed that the company is falling behind announced deadlines while incidents with EVs continue to rise.

    33
  • Bayer loses court fight over EU pesticides

    Bayer loses court fight over EU pesticides

    The German chemical conglomerate Bayer lost an appeal in EU court against a ban related to the usage of pesticides amid growing concerns linked to the extinction on bees, Reuters reported. The European Union's top court upheld the EU's partial ban on insecticides linked to harming bees, preventing their use on certain crops. Bayer appealed to overturn a lower EU court's 2018 decision to uphold the EU ban.

    64