European court rules against Britain over mass surveillance

UK intelligence programme exposed by Snowden breached right to privacy, Strasbourg judges rule

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) said Thursday that British intelligence’s mass surveillance of private communications online is illegal. In a landmark ruling judges voted six to one the effort by its intelligence agency GCHQ for obtaining data from communications providers was "not in accordance with the law", and there were "insufficient safeguards in respect of confidential journalistic material". They also voted by five to two the mass trawling for information violated Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights guaranteeing the right to privacy. 

According to the Strasbourg court British intelligence agencies’ interception regime violated the right to a private and family life, since there was “insufficient oversight” over which communications were chosen for examination.
The ECHR, however, ruled that the processes used to share the intelligence with foreign governments was not in violation of privacy or human rights standards. The ruling, nevertheless, still marks the first major legal blow to U.K. intelligence’s bulk interception and surveillance of private messages.

Former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden first disclosed the practice in 2013, revealing that Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) had been intercepting and holding onto data about the private communications of millions of people after the September 11, 2001. Thousands of classified documents leaked by him proved Britain spied on foreign politicians at G20 summit meetings in London in 2009, and collected huge quantities of global email messages, Facebook posts, and internet histories and calls, which it shared with the NSA.

As a result, a group of 14 human rights organisations, journalists and privacy groups had told the court that the practices were in violation of human rights.

Snowden on Thursday tweeted that the judgement was a victory.

"For five long years, governments have denied that global mass surveillance violates of your rights. And for five long years, we have chased them through the doors of every court. Today, we won. Don't thank me: thank all of those who never stopped fighting."

Still, the verdict is not final and can be appealed.

Similar articles

  • Helsinki, Lyon named  EU Capitals of Smart Tourism 2019

    Helsinki, Lyon named EU Capitals of Smart Tourism 2019

    Helsinki and Lyon are the winners of the first edition of the European Capital of Smart Tourism competition, EC Press Service reported on Tuesday. The two cities have showcased how they can develop tourism sustainably, ensure accessibility to destinations, embrace the digital transformation and link tourism to cultural heritage.

  • Despite Brexit planning, EMA fears disruption for 39 medicines

    Despite Brexit planning, EMA fears disruption for 39 medicines

    Despite actions taken by companies to prepare for Brexit, there is still a risk of serious supply disruptions for 39 medicines as a result of Britain’s departure from the EU, the bloc’s drugs regulator said on Monday. While that is an improvement on the situation in July, when the European Medicines Agency warned about supply problems for 108 products, the watchdog said companies responsible for the remaining drugs needed to “step up their planning now”.

  • Tensions rise within ECB on financial risk-sharing

    Tensions rise within ECB on financial risk-sharing

    The ECB leaders are still unable to reach a consensus about financial risk-sharing within the Eurozone. Last Wednesday, President Mario Draghi argued that the Union needed more integrated risk-sharing between Member States to boost confidence and help avert future crises. But a day later Board member Jens Weidmann countered that it is too soon for such a risk to be shared more broadly across the Eurozone.